Captain Frosty's Fish: Delight in Fresh Seafood & Ice Cream at Cape Cod

Oh hi, me again. :) We scoped this place out again after remembering it from our previous two years of visiting. The lobster roll is the best and I can also say the salmon sandwich was equally as amazing.

Great service. Fast and great fish sandwich. Excellent lobster roll and quick service.

The clams were amazing! They were fresh and large and tasty. The onion rings were also top notch. However the lobster roll was disappointing and the fish and chips were very average (not bad just not flavorful). The outdoor atmosphere at the picnic tables was lovely. In the shoulder season, it was quick service and barely lines.

Delicious scallop plate topped off with amazing orange freeze, which featured their yummy vanilla soft serve. An absolute treat!! Lots of yummy fish plates with amazing ice cream concoctions for dessert

I heard this is the place to go for fried seafood plates on the cape so of course I had to come here. I went with the fried clam belly plate, which came with fries, coleslaw, and 2 clam fritters. I think it was a little under $30, which I thought was a little steep at first but they advertise on their website it's all fresh local seafood so can't complain! For being fried, the clams were still very very flavorful and not too heavy. Easily the best fried seafood I've had. The fries were also good, nice and crispy and not too thick. I wasn't a huge fan of the clam cakes but that's not to say they were bad, just not my thing. There was plenty of seating inside at 2:30 on a Thursday but I imagine it gets busy on weekends during lunchtime. The employees were also very friendly. Would love to come back next time I'm on the cape and try the scallops and the cherry dipped ice cream, both of which looked delicious!

This place is a Cape Cod treasure. Really good value with delicious quality food at a good price. Had a $22 lobster roll that was excellent. Had a super tasty fish and chips and a Caesar salad. Love this place.

This place is adorable, the space is clean, well thought out, and comfortable. We were able to sit in the back patio which was lovely, plenty of shade. It's a no frills place, but the service was good! Really impressed given that almost everyone working there is young. The food is fresh and made to order and the price is fair. The seafood is definitely the star with minimum seasoning (I thought it could do with some salt and lemon but that's a personal preference). Great soft serve. This place is busy and for good reason, if you're in the area, it's worth a stop!